While heavily shorted stocks show some correlation with distress measures, the connection is weak. Factors like valuation, market sentiment, and strategic hedging often drive short positions beyond distress signals. We used our Black App and available market data to provide this analysis.
We examined three measures of bearishness for stocks: average analyst ratings (ranging from 1 to 5), CDS spreads, which reflect the cost to insure a company’s bonds and serve as a measure of bankruptcy risk, and the Altman Z-Score, a metric that uses fundamental indicators to estimate the probability of bankruptcy.
Our analysis reveals that while there is a statistically significant correlation between the size of short positions and these distress measures, the correlation is relatively weak, with a coefficient of only 0.20.
This suggests that although there is some relationship between heavy shorting and distress indicators, it is not strong.
Several factors could explain this low correlation. First, investors might short stocks based on valuation concerns rather than specific distress signals. This implies that valuation-driven shorts are not necessarily linked to distress indicators.
Additionally, short positions might be part of broader strategies or hedging activities unrelated to distress. Investors may use short positions for hedging or other market-neutral strategies that do not relate to a company's distress.
Black APP, Macro, % of Float
In examining specific cases, we identified notable outliers. For instance, American Airlines (AAL) has a high short position (18.39%), but a moderate CDS spread (200 basis points) and a low Altman Z-Score, indicating minimal bankruptcy risk. This discrepancy suggests that despite moderate distress signals, AAL is heavily shorted, possibly due to specific market views or factors not captured by these metrics.
Conversely, the U.S. Dollar (USD) has a low short position (1.32%), but a high CDS spread (1000 basis points), indicating high perceived distress despite minimal short interest. This could be attributed to factors such as currency market dynamics or investor sentiment.
Another example is Super Micro Computer (SMCI), which has a high short position (16%) but a high Altman Z-Score (10), indicating a minimal risk of bankruptcy. The contrast between the high rating and low distress signals, along with the significant short position, suggests that other factors might be influencing short interest.
In summary, the weak correlation between short positions and distress measures indicates that not all heavily shorted stocks are distressed according to traditional metrics. Short interest can arise from numerous factors beyond immediate distress signals, including valuation concerns, market sentiment, and strategic considerations. Individual cases like AAL and SMCI illustrate that other elements might be influencing short positions beyond standard distress indicators.
Want to know more?
Access this data in real time using S3’s BLACK APP or Contact us to get started.
