Author:
Ihor Dusaniwsky
Managing Director of Predictive Analytics, S3 Partners
Matthew Unterman
Director of Predictive Analytics, S3 Partners
Barclays Bank announced that it will be halting new creations and discontinue sales from its inventory of the iPath Series B S&P 500 VIX Short-Term Futures ETF (VXX) and iPath Pure Beta Crude Oil ETN (OIL). This action not only affects long shareholders but also short sellers. While the OIL ETF has minimal short interest ($3.04 million of short interest, 0.10 million shares shorted), short sellers are very active in the VXX ETF. VXX short interest is $891 million, 30.92 million shares shorted, 92.98% SI % Float. The S3 SI % Float (which includes the synthetic longs created by every short sale in the Float denominator) is 48.17%. The stock borrow rate is 3.57% and should be increasing as borrow supply dwindles. VXX is the 47th largest ETF short.
#
ETF
Ticker
SI % Float
S3 SI % Float
Fee
Short Interest
1
SPDR S&P 500 ETF
SPY
17.75%
15.07%
0.30%
$67,057,171,605
2
ISHS RUSSELL 2000 ETF
IWM
39.67%
28.40%
0.69%
$23,517,968,418
3
INVESCO QQQ TRUST ETF
QQQ
13.70%
12.05%
0.30%
$23,203,776,023
4
ISHS IBOXX $ HIGH YIELD CORP BOND ETF
HYG
57.03%
36.32%
3.57%
$8,896,538,227
5
ISHS IBOXX $ INV GRD CORP BOND ETF
LQD
16.89%
14.45%
0.94%
$5,580,400,326
6
SPDR FINANCIAL SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLF
11.16%
10.04%
0.30%
$4,770,933,185
7
SPDR SP OIL\GAS EXPLOR\PROD ETF
XOP
82.50%
45.21%
1.20%
$4,725,796,600
8
ISHS MSCI EAFE ETF
EFA
7.64%
7.10%
0.57%
$3,839,873,236
9
ISHS MSCI EMERGING MARKETS ETF
EEM
16.32%
14.03%
0.30%
$3,486,717,267
10
SPDR INDUSTRIAL SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLI
22.30%
18.23%
0.30%
$3,479,059,591
11
ISHS 20+ YR TREAS BOND ETF
TLT
18.59%
15.67%
0.30%
$3,039,404,368
12
SPDR ENERGY SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLE
7.35%
6.85%
0.30%
$2,735,213,184
13
SPDR S&P BIOTECH ETF
XBI
45.25%
31.16%
1.07%
$2,699,631,000
14
SPDR S&P REGIONAL BANKING ETF
KRE
46.75%
31.86%
1.07%
$2,490,661,459
15
INVESCO S&P 500 EQUAL WEIGHT ETF
RSP
7.72%
7.17%
0.69%
$2,437,139,070
16
SPDR DJIA ETF
DIA
8.51%
7.85%
0.30%
$2,406,709,696
17
SPDR HEALTH CARE SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLV
6.70%
6.28%
0.30%
$2,286,343,744
18
SPDR UTILITIES SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLU
20.38%
16.93%
0.30%
$2,286,258,219
19
VNGRD S&P 500 ETF
VOO
0.82%
0.82%
0.30%
$2,194,151,525
20
ISHS JPM $ EMERGING MARKETS BOND ETF
EMB
12.96%
11.47%
0.57%
$2,122,010,684
47
IPATH SERIES B SP 500 VIX ST FUT ETN
VXX
92.98%
48.18%
4.32%
$890,816,023
Total ETF Short Interest
-
23.59%
15.47%
0.96%
$256,881,891,951
Over the past thirty days we have seen +$142 million of new short selling in the VXX ETF, the 16th largest amount of new short selling over the last thirty days for all ETFs.
#
ETF
Ticker
Short Interest
30 Day Change Shares Shorted
1
SPDR S&P 500 ETF
SPY
$67,057,171,605
$5,505,506,343
2
VNGRD S&P 500 ETF
VOO
$2,194,151,525
$617,087,277
3
VNGRD ST CORP BOND ETF
VCSH
$1,159,491,609
$605,249,638
4
ISHS CORE MSCI EAFE ETF
IEFA
$1,640,435,809
$552,383,919
5
ISHS MSCI EAFE ETF
EFA
$3,839,873,236
$467,169,229
6
SPDR S&P REGIONAL BANKING ETF
KRE
$2,490,661,459
$314,637,718
7
INVESCO SENIOR LOAN ETF
BKLN
$1,929,904,861
$299,411,916
8
ISHS IBOXX $ HIGH YIELD CORP BOND ETF
HYG
$8,896,538,227
$270,453,190
9
ISHS CORE MSCI EMERGING MARKETS ETF
IEMG
$366,216,483
$225,581,258
10
ISHS CHINA LARGE CAP ETF
FXI
$968,866,526
$196,309,888
11
SPDR BLACKSTONE SENIOR LOAN ETF
SRLN
$803,962,122
$183,608,734
12
SPDR HEALTH CARE SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLV
$2,286,343,744
$159,388,018
13
VNGRD TOTAL WORLD STOCK ETF
VT
$485,890,364
$158,250,650
14
ISHS MSCI BRAZIL ETF
EWZ
$1,578,304,625
$155,050,055
15
ISHS RUSSELL 1000 ETF
IWB
$815,584,950
$150,039,651
16
IPATH SERIES B SP 500 VIX ST FUT ETN
VXX
$890,816,023
$142,175,987
17
ISHS MSCI TAIWAN CAPPED ETF
EWT
$518,126,427
$140,418,896
18
SPDR UTILITIES SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLU
$2,286,258,219
$127,672,671
19
SPDR S&P MIDCAP ETF
MDY
$1,453,752,912
$122,201,165
20
VNGRD EUROPEAN ETF
VGK
$409,849,753
$120,578,284
Total ETF 30D Change Shares Shorted
-
$256,881,891,951
$3,506,109,833
There has been net short selling over the last thirty days for the VXX, with shares shorted increasing by 4.9 million shares, worth $142 million. This is a +19% increase in shares shorted as its stock price rose +24%. But over the last week we have seen a change in short-side sentiment with 1.5 million of short covering, worth $43 million, a -4.6 decrease in shares shorted as its stock price rose 1.1%.
VXX short sellers are giving back some of their 2021 profits this year. After being up +$744.5 million in 2021 mark-to-market profits (a +131.20% return on an average short interest of $567 million), shorts are down -$301.7 million in year-to-date mark-to-market losses for 2022 (down -48.20% on an average short interest of $626 million). Shorts are down -$174.1 million in March mark-to-market losses, -20.19%, after being down -$27.5 million on the +3.09% price move on March 15.
The definition of a “crowded” short trade varies from investor to investor but there are several themes that remain constant. A short can be considered to be “crowded” if some or all of the following occur: there are large amount of dollars at risk on the short side, a large proportion of a stock’s float is being shorted, there is illiquidity in the stock loan market and\or there is illiquidity in the trading market. ETF Crowdedness is a very volatile number as daily creations and redemptions can change a particular ETF Crowded score significantly on a day-to-day basis.
The VXX ETF is the 12th most Crowded ETF trading in the U.S. (ETFs with over $25 million of short interest). VXX’s relatively large dollar short interest ($891 million), high stock borrow fee (4.32% fee and rising versus the U.S. ETF average of 0.96% fee), high SI % Float (92.98% versus 23.59% U.S. ETF average) and high S3 SI % Float of 48.18% versus 15.47% U.S. ETF average.
#
ETF
Ticker
Short Interest
S3 Crowded Score
S3 Squeeze Score
1
INVESCO SENIOR LOAN ETF
BKLN
$1,929,904,861
95.00
95.00
2
SPDR S&P RETAIL ETF
XRT
$2,120,252,896
92.50
92.50
3
ISHS IBOXX $ HIGH YIELD CORP BOND ETF
HYG
$8,896,538,227
90.00
90.00
4
ISHS RUSSELL 2000 ETF
IWM
$23,517,968,418
85.00
85.00
5
SPDR SP OIL\GAS EXPLOR\PROD ETF
XOP
$4,725,796,600
85.00
85.00
6
SPDR S&P BIOTECH ETF
XBI
$2,699,631,000
82.50
72.50
7
SPDR S&P REGIONAL BANKING ETF
KRE
$2,490,661,459
82.50
82.50
8
ISHS N AMER TECH-SOFTWARE ETF
IGV
$1,758,325,882
82.50
62.50
9
ISHS RUSS 2000 GROWTH ETF
IWO
$1,860,556,804
80.00
80.00
10
SPDR BBERG HIGH YIELD BOND ETF
JNK
$1,932,211,055
77.50
77.50
11
SPDR S&P HOMEBUILDERS ETF
XHB
$912,267,204
77.50
77.50
12
IPATH SERIES B SP 500 VIX ST FUT ETN
VXX
$890,816,023
77.50
97.50
13
ISHS MSCI TURKEY ETF
TUR
$58,315,004
77.50
77.50
14
ISHS MSCI BRAZIL ETF
EWZ
$1,578,304,625
75.00
65.00
15
VANECK SEMICONDUCTOR ETF
SMH
$1,963,504,040
70.00
60.00
16
ISHS US HOME CONSTRUCTION ETF
ITB
$633,145,390
70.00
60.00
17
SPDR INDUSTRIAL SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLI
$3,479,059,591
67.50
67.50
18
ISHS DJ US R.E. ETF
IYR
$1,471,769,837
67.50
67.50
19
ISHS MSCI MEXICO ETF
EWW
$205,441,869
67.50
67.50
20
DRXN NASDAQ-100 EQUAL WEIGHTED ETF
QQQE
$105,543,515
67.50
47.50
Not every Crowded stock is a Squeeze candidate. By overlaying our Squeeze algorithm over our Crowded Score, we can determine which U.S. traded stocks have the highest potential for a Squeeze, and which do not.
The VXX ETF is the most squeezable ETF in the U.S. market with a score or 97.50/100.00. Its Crowdedness coupled with over -20% of market-to-market losses over the last thirty days may chase some short sellers out of their positions.
#
ETF
Ticker
Short Interest
Crowded Score
Squeeze Score
1
IPATH SERIES B SP 500 VIX ST FUT ETN
VXX
$890,816,023
77.50
97.50
2
INVESCO SENIOR LOAN ETF
BKLN
$1,929,904,861
95.00
95.00
3
SPDR S&P RETAIL ETF
XRT
$2,120,252,896
92.50
92.50
4
ISHS IBOXX $ HIGH YIELD CORP BOND ETF
HYG
$8,896,538,227
90.00
90.00
5
ISHS RUSSELL 2000 ETF
IWM
$23,517,968,418
85.00
85.00
6
SPDR SP OIL\GAS EXPLOR\PROD ETF
XOP
$4,725,796,600
85.00
85.00
7
PROSHS ULTRA 1.5X VIX S.T. FUTURES ETF
UVXY
$207,624,665
65.00
85.00
8
SPDR S&P REGIONAL BANKING ETF
KRE
$2,490,661,459
82.50
82.50
9
ISHS RUSS 2000 GROWTH ETF
IWO
$1,860,556,804
80.00
80.00
10
SPDR BBERG HIGH YIELD BOND ETF
JNK
$1,932,211,055
77.50
77.50
11
SPDR S&P HOMEBUILDERS ETF
XHB
$912,267,204
77.50
77.50
12
ISHS MSCI TURKEY ETF
TUR
$58,315,004
77.50
77.50
13
SPDR S&P BIOTECH ETF
XBI
$2,699,631,000
82.50
72.50
14
SPDR INDUSTRIAL SELECT SECTOR ETF
XLI
$3,479,059,591
67.50
67.50
15
ISHS DJ US R.E. ETF
IYR
$1,471,769,837
67.50
67.50
16
ISHS MSCI MEXICO ETF
EWW
$205,441,869
67.50
67.50
17
ISHS INTL DEV SMALL CAP VALUE FACTOR ETF
ISVL
$47,977,941
67.50
67.50
18
ISHS MSCI BRAZIL ETF
EWZ
$1,578,304,625
75.00
65.00
19
ISHS IBOXX $ INV GRD CORP BOND ETF
LQD
$5,580,400,326
65.00
65.00
20
ISHS NASDAQ BIOTECH ETF
IBB
$1,340,936,662
65.00
65.00
Our Crowded and Squeeze scores take into account normal market activities such as buying\selling, price moves, trading volumes and stock borrow activity but the VXX ETF is now experiencing a unique systemic factor which makes it even more Squeezable than its score. With Barclays Bank not issuing any more shares either from its inventory or through new ETF creations, the VXX ETF will now act more like a closed end fund rather than an ETF with variable shares outstanding. In addition, as VXX ETF shares get redeemed, we will see shares outstanding decrease over time.
With shares outstanding temporarily maxed out at this share level, excessive buy-side or sell-side demand may force the VXX ETF to trade at a premium or discount to its NAV, producing outsized gains and losses relative to the underlying futures contracts that its price should be based on.
On the stock borrow side, if long shareholders that are lending their shares sell some or all of their positions, there is less of a chance to find replacement stock borrows and the amount of street recalls should increase substantially.
With a greater possibility of stock borrow financing rates increasing, stock recall frequency increasing and stock price volatility increasing the Squeezability of the VXX ETF should top out at the 100.00/100.00 level soon. If the VXX ETF stock price continues to trend upwards, we should start seeing short covering as net-of-financing mark-to-market losses force short sellers out of their positions.