Renowned Shorts Take On SunRun

Author:

Ihor Dusaniwsky

Managing Director of Predictive Analytics, S3 Partners

Matthew Unterman

Director of Predictive Analytics, S3 Partners

September 30, 2022

SunRun Inc (RUN), a provider of residential solar energy installations, was a shorts-side candidate at CNBC’s “Delivering Alpha” Conference. Jim Chanos, founder of Kynikos Associates Ltd, and Carson Block, CEO/CIO of Muddy Waters Capital LLC, both expressed their short-side thesis for SunRun. While the Inflation Reduction Act and energy cost inflation have provided juice to the growing green energy market both Chanos and Block were suspicious of SunRun’s high valuation versus its revenue and debt situation, at one point characterizing SunRun as the “aluminum siding of the 21st century.”

RUN is one of the most shorted companies in the Electrical Equipment industry with short interest of $724.9 million, 23.33 million shares shorted, 11.39% SI % Float and 10.23% S3 SI % Float (which includes the synthetic longs created by every short sale in the trade float denominator) and a stock borrow fee of 0.30% (General Collateral).

Short Interest in Electrical Equipment Industry (as of 09.30.22)

Name

Ticker

SI % Float

S3 SI % Float

Fee

Short Interest

PLUG POWER INC

PLUG

11.73%

10.50%

0.30%

$ 1,355,660,505

GENERAC HLDGS

GNRC

10.78%

9.73%

0.30%

$ 1,269,086,427

SUNRUN INC

RUN

11.39%

10.23%

0.30%

$ 724,868,724

CHARGEPOINT HOLDINGS INC

CHPT

23.54%

19.05%

2.32%

$ 655,583,984

EATON CORP PLC

ETN

1.01%

1.00%

0.30%

$ 535,021,068

ROCKWELL AUTOMATION

ROK

1.70%

1.67%

0.30%

$ 424,943,828

SUNPOWER CORP

SPWR

19.38%

16.24%

0.30%

$ 405,136,107

BLOOM ENERGY CORP

BE

10.55%

9.54%

0.30%

$ 393,657,468

EMERSON ELECTRIC CO

EMR

0.85%

0.85%

0.30%

$ 375,475,550

ARRAY TECHNOLOGIES INC

ARRY

13.56%

11.94%

0.30%

$ 339,180,215

ENCORE WIRE CORP

WIRE

14.14%

12.39%

0.30%

$ 304,437,863

ACUITY BRANDS INC

AYI

5.83%

5.51%

0.30%

$ 296,733,997

ENOVIX CORP

ENVX

11.99%

10.71%

0.57%

$ 242,977,141

HUBBELL INC

HUBB

1.86%

1.83%

0.30%

$ 220,814,520

AMETEK INC

AME

0.84%

0.83%

0.30%

$ 219,582,407

FUELCELL ENERGY INC

FCEL

14.66%

12.78%

0.30%

$ 211,220,873

BLINK CHARGING CO

BLNK

26.10%

20.70%

14.57%

$ 204,728,612

BALLARD POWER SYSTEMS

BLDP

12.04%

10.74%

0.82%

$ 196,123,252

STEM INC

STEM

11.13%

10.02%

0.30%

$ 193,519,066

ATKORE INTL GRP

ATKR

6.23%

5.86%

0.30%

$ 190,882,017

Total Electrical Equipment Industry Short Interest

9.74%

8.54%

1.34%

$ 10,864,888,487

Short interest in the Electrical Equipment industry has declined over the last thirty days, declining from $11.8 billion to $10.9 billion, which was due primarily to the decline in the mark-to-market prices of the share shorted. Over the last thirty days we saw a $1.4 billion decline in the mark-to-market value of shares shored offset partially by $533 million of new short selling. Short sellers were partially replenishing their short exposure as the stock prices of their shorts declined – backing up their bets on a hot craps table.

The stocks with the largest increase in shares shorted over the last thirty days, a sign that shorts continue to be bearish in these short positions, are below.

Electrical Equipment Stocks with Highest 30 Day Increase in Shares Shorted

Name

Ticker

SI % Float

S3 SI % Float

Fee

Short Interest

30D Ch Shares Shorted

AMETEK INC

AME

0.84%

0.83%

0.30%

$ 219,582,407

$84,833,609

EATON CORP PLC

ETN

1.01%

1.00%

0.30%

$535,021,068

$73,208,557

ARRAY TECHNOLOGIES INC

ARRY

13.56%

11.94%

0.30%

$339,180,215

$62,792,216

GENERAC HLDGS

GNRC

10.78%

9.73%

0.30%

$1,269,086,427

$57,079,516

CHARGEPOINT HOLDINGS INC

CHPT

23.54%

19.05%

2.32%

$655,583,984

$51,064,539

While the stocks with the largest increase in short covering over the last thirty days, a sign that short side conviction is waning, are below.

Electrical Equipment Stocks with Highest 30 Day Change in Short Covering

Name

Ticker

SI % Float

S3 SI % Float

Fee

Short Interest

30D Ch Shs Shorted

PLUG POWER INC

PLUG

11.73%

10.50%

0.30%

$1,355,660,505

$(95,508,106)

SUNRUN INC

RUN

11.39%

10.23%

0.30%

$724,868,724

$(81,348,987)

ENOVIX CORP

ENVX

11.99%

10.71%

0.57%

$242,977,141

$(21,045,617)

HUBBELL INC

HUBB

1.86%

1.83%

0.30%

$220,814,520

$(8,172,197)

BLINK CHARGING CO

BLNK

26.10%

20.70%

14.57%

$204,728,612

$(6,714,745)

RUN had the second largest amount of short covering in the Electric Equipment industry over the last thirty days, but this short covering has been a trend since March. Since February 28th RUN shorts have bought-to-cover 16.2 million shares, worth $503 million, a 41.0% decrease in total shares shorted as its stock price rose +13.9%. Run short sellers have been actively reducing their exposure in the stock for most of the year.

My image alt text

Shorting RUN has been a profitable trade in 2022 but it has underperformed the short-side returns of the Electrical Equipment industry.

RUN shorts are up $17.3 million in year-to-date mark-to-market profits, a +1.98% return on an average short interest of $872 million. Severely underperforming the Electrical Equipment industry average short-side return of +25.25%.

YTD Average Short Interest

YTD Mark-Market Profit\Loss

Profit\Loss %

Electrical Equipment Industry

$10,656,180,810

$2,691,015,369

25.25%

SunRun Inc (RUN)

$871,921,117

$17,304,932

1.98%

RUN short-side returns underperformed the industry average over the last thirty days as well, but not quite as badly. RUN shorts were up $56.6 million in thirty-day mark-to-market profits, a +6.49% return on an average short interest of $871 million – half the electrical Equipment industry average return of +13.45%.

30D Average Short Interest

30D Mark-Market Profit\Loss

Profit\Loss %

Electrical Equipment Industry

$11,603,236,908

$1,560,382,847

13.45%

SunRun Inc (RUN)

$871,415,537

$56,553,715

6.49%

While Chanos and Block are actively tweeting about and shorting RUN, we have seen short covering in the stock for most of the year. We will see if two high profile short sellers can sway the market and reverse RUN’s short covering trend. Recent price weakness in RUN may temper short covering but if RUN’s stock price reverses course and heads back towards $35/share we should see an acceleration of short covering that we saw historically at those price levels. It will be interesting to see of Chanos and Block and can short-side RUN momentum their way.

Related Articles