Author:
Ihor Dusaniwsky
Managing Director of Predictive Analytics, S3 Partners
Matthew Unterman
Director of Predictive Analytics, S3 Partners
With the markets giving back more than half of their November positive returns in the first week of December we are seeing short sellers reverse course and are now short selling into the recent market downturn after a month of short covering in November.
DATE
S&P 500
Nasdaq
Russell 3000
S&P/TSX
November Returns
5.38%
4.09%
5.02%
5.29%
December Returns
-3.58%
-4.19%
-3.72%
-2.35%
Short interest in the U.S.\Canada markets decreased by -$30.7 billion, or -3.2%, to $941 billion in the December of 2022. The $30.7 billion decrease was made up of $38.5 billion in shorted share price decreases partially offset by $7.8 billion of new short selling.
Short Interest by Sector: As of 12.8.22
Sector
11/30/22 Short Interest
12/7/22 Short Interest
Dec. Change Short Interest
Dec. Change Shares Shorted
Dec. Change Mark-to-Market
Communication Services
$67,181,764,336
$65,111,862,566
($2,069,901,770)
$519,875,701
($2,589,777,471)
Consumer Discretionary
$153,143,001,665
$147,511,443,681
($5,631,557,984)
$1,407,142,997
($7,038,700,981)
Consumer Staples
$44,402,828,624
$43,656,011,935
($746,816,689)
($88,924,010)
($657,892,679)
Energy
$77,450,093,486
$71,998,128,271
($5,451,965,215)
$465,790,261
($5,917,755,476)
Financials
$115,967,637,749
$111,648,308,808
($4,319,328,941)
$1,235,049,876
($5,554,378,817)
Health Care
$127,085,036,928
$126,668,412,460
($416,624,468)
$1,770,109,299
($2,186,733,767)
Industrials
$101,914,041,619
$98,928,212,218
($2,985,829,401)
$691,136,617
($3,676,966,018)
Information Technology
$179,368,872,927
$171,323,047,945
($8,045,824,982)
$1,111,424,333
($9,157,249,315)
Materials
$41,817,150,095
$41,554,155,123
($262,994,972)
($337,005,316)
$74,010,344
Misc. (SPACs)
$556,775,891
$521,532,742
($35,243,149)
($6,516,500)
($28,726,649)
Real Estate
$38,874,318,813
$38,430,176,790
($444,142,023)
$797,625,776
($1,241,767,799)
Utilities
$24,131,134,548
$23,826,516,544
($304,618,004)
$218,441,964
($523,059,968)
Total U.S.\Canada Short Interest
$971,892,656,681
$941,177,809,081
($30,714,847,600)
$7,784,150,997
($38,498,998,597)
Every sector had a decrease of short exposure in December with Information Technology (-$8.0 billion), Consumer Discretionary (-$5.6 billion) and Energy (-$5.5 billion) having the largest decreases of short interest in December.
In response to this sudden and dramatic downward move in the market, short sellers were most actively shorting Health Care (+1.8 billion), Consumer Discretionary (+$1.4 billion), Financials (+$1.2 billion and Information Technology (+1.1 billion).
This reverses a portion of the short covering we saw in November. The sectors with the largest amount of short covering in November were Healthcare (+$4.8 billion), Financials (+$4.5 billion) and Consumer Discretionary (+$3.5 billion).
Short Selling by Sector: Through November 2022
Sector
10/31/22 Short Interest
11/30/22 Short Interest
Nov. Change Short Interest
Nov. Change Shares Shorted
Nov. Change Mark-to-Market
Communication Services
$64,555,360,658
$67,181,764,336
$2,626,403,678
($1,031,747,484)
$3,658,151,162
Consumer Discretionary
$147,830,611,181
$153,143,001,665
$5,312,390,484
($3,459,741,097)
$8,772,131,581
Consumer Staples
$43,136,867,496
$44,402,828,624
$1,265,961,128
($1,169,384,616)
$2,435,345,744
Energy
$77,689,755,188
$77,450,093,486
($239,661,702)
($850,713,158)
$611,051,456
Financials
$114,608,678,519
$115,967,637,749
$1,358,959,230
($4,487,092,351)
$5,846,051,581
Health Care
$127,126,989,474
$127,085,036,928
($41,952,546)
($4,792,888,505)
$4,750,935,959
Industrials
$98,743,340,100
$101,914,041,619
$3,170,701,519
($2,711,245,125)
$5,881,946,644
Information Technology
$173,640,286,490
$179,368,872,927
$5,728,586,437
($1,011,133,423)
$6,739,719,860
Materials
$38,315,826,045
$41,817,150,095
$3,501,324,050
($352,289,039)
$3,853,613,089
Misc. (SPACs)
$531,258,234
$556,775,891
$25,517,657
$26,837,850
($1,320,193)
Real Estate
$37,254,346,443
$38,874,318,813
$1,619,972,370
($668,717,958)
$2,288,690,328
Utilities
$24,413,058,910
$24,131,134,548
($281,924,362)
($1,721,266,395)
$1,439,342,033
Total U.S.\Canada Short Interest
$947,846,378,739
$971,892,656,681
$24,046,277,942
($22,229,381,302)
$46,275,659,244
Short sellers are up $38.4 billion in December net-of-financing mark-to-market profits, up +4.02%. These profits cover four-fifths of the $47.4 billion of net-of-financing mark-to-market losses they incurred in November.
Sector
Dec. MTM PL
P\L %
Nov. MTM PL
P\L %
Communication Services
$2,579,719,531
3.90%
($3,780,609,504)
-5.74%
Consumer Discretionary
$7,023,502,599
4.67%
($8,490,031,724)
-5.64%
Consumer Staples
$651,680,961
1.48%
($2,373,477,764)
-5.42%
Energy
$5,893,417,742
7.89%
($930,316,134)
-1.20%
Financials
$5,433,443,765
4.77%
($5,632,078,050)
-4.89%
Health Care
$2,212,372,725
1.74%
($4,719,246,870)
-3.71%
Industrials
$3,647,826,372
3.63%
($5,743,761,867)
-5.72%
Information Technology
$8,557,120,923
4.88%
($7,618,887,646)
-4.32%
Materials
$696,557,943
1.67%
($4,678,404,091)
-11.68%
Misc. (SPACs)
$3,393,986
0.63%
($32,188,359)
-5.92%
Real Estate
$1,245,178,231
3.22%
($2,133,610,944)
-5.61%
Utilities
$492,712,200
2.05%
($1,314,655,780)
-5.42%
Total U.S.\Canada MTM P\L
$38,436,926,978
4.02%
($47,447,268,731)
-4.94%
Stocks with the largest net-of-financing mark-to-market profits in December were:
Name
Ticker
Avg Fee
Avg Short Interest
Dec. MTM P\L
P\L %
TESLA INC
TSLA US
0.30%
$14,377,954,949
$1,561,474,166
10.86%
APPLE INC
AAPL US
0.30%
$16,994,631,106
$822,658,063
4.84%
AMAZON.COM INC
AMZN US
0.30%
$7,712,841,956
$668,929,050
8.67%
BANK OF AMERICA
BAC US
0.30%
$2,599,628,712
$375,240,766
14.43%
VISA INC
V US
0.30%
$8,287,392,730
$345,382,259
4.17%
MICROSOFT CORP
MSFT US
0.30%
$8,059,055,838
$344,249,310
4.27%
MIRATI THERAPEUTICS
MRTX US
0.30%
$667,743,920
$321,546,479
48.15%
OCCIDENTAL PETRO
OXY US
0.30%
$3,869,000,687
$318,925,925
8.24%
ALPHABET INC - A
GOOGL US
0.30%
$5,206,869,544
$315,704,502
6.06%
ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES
AMD US
0.30%
$3,027,482,020
$300,204,142
9.92%
EXXON MOBIL CORP
XOM US
0.30%
$4,156,009,060
$293,771,988
7.07%
NVIDIA CORP
NVDA US
0.30%
$6,016,167,762
$290,835,939
4.83%
SALESFORCE.COM INC
CRM US
0.30%
$1,312,030,415
$272,185,983
20.75%
BLACKSTONE GRP LP
BX US
0.30%
$1,586,774,501
$259,813,268
16.37%
COSTCO WHOLESALE
COST US
0.30%
$2,139,740,216
$247,369,008
11.56%
AVIS BUDGET GROUP INC
CAR US
0.30%
$1,375,416,909
$217,215,355
15.79%
GAMESTOP CORP
GME US
8.07%
$1,402,566,361
$211,629,425
15.09%
ALPHABET INC - C
GOOG US
0.30%
$3,261,688,995
$205,379,740
6.30%
LUCID GROUP INC
LCID US
8.98%
$1,288,792,879
$201,348,062
15.62%
ENBRIDGE INC
ENB US
0.30%
$3,913,805,668
$195,539,501
5.00%
And the stocks with the largest percentage net-of-financing mark-to-market profits with over $250 million in short interest in December were:
Name
Ticker
Avg Fee
Avg Short Interest
Dec. MTM P\L
P\L %
CARVANA CO
CVNA US
5.82%
$269,028,715
$141,758,523
52.69%
MIRATI THERAPEUTICS
MRTX US
0.30%
$667,743,920
$321,546,479
48.15%
INTELLIA THERAPEUTICS INC
NTLA US
0.30%
$283,452,620
$85,520,148
30.17%
ASANA INC
ASAN US
0.57%
$268,449,879
$80,833,643
30.11%
APPLOVIN CORP
APP US
0.30%
$272,595,475
$73,408,166
26.93%
NRG ENERGY INC
NRG US
0.30%
$568,681,457
$133,863,757
23.54%
SWEETGREEN INC
SG US
0.82%
$263,803,202
$60,248,111
22.84%
COMSTOCK RESOURCES INC
CRK US
0.30%
$311,664,825
$70,024,328
22.47%
OLLIES BARGAIN OUTLET
OLLI US
0.30%
$507,758,653
$113,814,866
22.42%
BIOCRYST PHARMA
BCRX US
0.30%
$333,300,347
$71,822,155
21.55%
SALESFORCE.COM INC
CRM US
0.30%
$1,312,030,415
$272,185,983
20.75%
AFFIRM HLDGS INC
AFRM US
0.57%
$557,286,772
$105,144,053
18.87%
SL GREEN REALTY CORP
SLG US
0.30%
$354,109,265
$66,161,738
18.68%
PBF ENERGY INC
PBF US
0.30%
$310,374,587
$57,862,085
18.64%
SIGNATURE BK NY
SBNY US
0.30%
$299,143,173
$51,270,650
17.14%
VORNADO REALTY
VNO US
0.30%
$442,253,588
$74,389,085
16.82%
ZIM INTEGRATED SHIPPING SVCS LTD
ZIM US
6.07%
$268,979,717
$45,243,388
16.82%
NORDSTROM INC
JWN US
0.30%
$461,484,672
$76,022,776
16.47%
ELASTIC NV
ESTC US
0.30%
$290,550,590
$47,848,848
16.47%
BLACKSTONE GRP LP
BX US
0.30%
$1,586,774,501
$259,813,268
16.37%
The volatility in the market has forced short sellers to react quickly to momentum trends. Traders are looking to be more efficient on the short side to effectively offset stock price moves on the long side. Hedge funds are finding it frustrating to be hedged on a notional basis, but their resulting combined long and short P\L does not perform as expected. The result is short exposure rising and falling in different industries when momentum trends are identified.
The industries with the largest increase in shares shorted in November – December are:
Industry
10/31/22 Short Interest
12/7/22 Short Interest
Change Short Interest
Change Shares Shorted
Change Mark-to-Market
Semiconductors & Semiconductor Equipment
$39,675,470,427
$47,045,505,396
$7,370,034,969
$2,642,632,675
$4,727,402,294
Technology Hardware Storage & Peripherals
$20,766,738,259
$21,689,984,161
$923,245,902
$2,164,785,491
($1,241,539,589)
Specialty Retail
$30,221,060,873
$32,205,439,445
$1,984,378,572
$770,143,599
$1,214,234,973
Interactive Media & Services
$17,457,266,512
$19,188,811,603
$1,731,545,091
$675,761,806
$1,055,783,285
Chemicals
$13,947,454,475
$14,829,383,740
$881,929,265
$630,185,604
$251,743,661
Equity Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)
$32,917,969,476
$34,067,839,814
$1,149,870,338
$484,037,935
$665,832,403
Multiline Retail
$7,224,820,936
$7,313,760,462
$88,939,526
$448,303,686
($359,364,160)
Road & Rail
$14,632,030,040
$14,902,623,881
$270,593,841
$254,798,952
$15,794,889
Automobiles
$28,614,814,807
$24,237,395,935
($4,377,418,872)
$174,188,309
($4,551,607,181)
Food Products
$12,350,633,252
$12,672,718,455
$322,085,203
$128,030,964
$194,054,239
The industries with the largest increase in shares covered in November – December are:
Industry
10/31/22 Short Interest
12/7/22 Short Interest
Change Short Interest
Change Shares Shorted
Change Mark-to-Market
Software
$57,706,528,867
$49,673,872,096
($8,032,656,771)
($3,940,887,197)
($4,091,769,574)
Banks
$49,919,643,579
$47,054,832,909
($2,864,810,670)
($2,285,713,382)
($579,097,288)
Biotechnology
$43,749,279,076
$42,834,801,614
($914,477,462)
($1,677,736,298)
$763,258,836
Electric Utilities
$12,765,124,867
$12,366,142,750
($398,982,117)
($1,047,931,543)
$648,949,426
Metals & Mining
$17,920,750,753
$20,194,477,893
$2,273,727,140
($994,290,971)
$3,268,018,111
Internet & Direct Marketing Retail
$24,054,718,412
$25,885,401,942
$1,830,683,530
($953,055,058)
$2,783,738,588
Hotels Restaurants & Leisure
$27,761,554,488
$27,707,188,020
($54,366,468)
($729,182,019)
$674,815,551
Food & Staples Retailing
$11,457,802,249
$11,058,215,655
($399,586,594)
($691,851,025)
$292,264,431
Entertainment
$18,362,332,360
$17,595,130,404
($767,201,956)
($686,330,687)
($80,871,269)
Household Durables
$8,264,661,103
$8,150,557,549
($114,103,554)
($621,073,661)
$506,970,107
The following are the biggest stock movers in the industries with the most short selling short in November-December:
Industry
Ticker
Short Selling ($ millions)
Semiconductor & Semiconductor Equipment
NVDA US
$ 718
-
AMD US
$ 689
-
AVGO US
$ 491
-
KLAC US
$ 470
Tech Hardware Storage & Peripherals
AAPL US
$ 1,971
-
HPQ US
$ 199
-
WDC US
$ 52
Specialty Retail
HD US
$ 664
-
KMX US
$ 255
-
FND US
$ 177
-
LOW US
$ 173
The following are the biggest stock movers in the industries the with most short covering in November-December:
Industry
Ticker
Short Covering ($ millions)
Software
MSFT US
$ (1,109)
-
U US
$ (335)
-
PANW US
$ (306)
-
INTU US
$ (276)
-
WDAY US
$ (230)
Banks
RY US
$ (926)
-
BMO US
$ (434)
-
BNS US
$ (386)
-
BAC US
$ (229)
-
PNC US
$ (262)
Biotechnology
MRNA US
$ (278)
-
AMGN US
$ (190)
-
ASND US
$ (185)
-
BMRN US
$ (149)
-
ALNY US
$ (140)
-
ABBV US
$ (134)
Electric Utilities
ETR US
$ (450)
-
PCG US
$ (408)
-
SO US
$ (132)
-
NEE US
$ (95)
If market weakness continues, we should see continued short selling across all sectors and follow the trend that we identified in the first week of December. But if the market whipsaws once again and the Santa Claus rally does appear, we will probably see much of this recent short selling reversed with short covering and the November trend of market wide short covering return.